CMC Markets is the stronger overall broker, earning our rating of 4.0/5 compared to Freetrade's 3.0/5. With multi-jurisdictional regulation, access to over 10,000 instruments across six market categories, and professional-grade platforms including MT4, CMC Markets dominates on depth and versatility. Freetrade earns its place for absolute beginners who want zero-commission stock and ETF investing through a clean mobile app — but it simply cannot compete on range, regulation breadth, or trading infrastructure.
Regulation & Safety
CMC Markets was founded in 1989 and carries over three decades of regulatory compliance behind it. It holds licences from three of the world's most respected financial regulators: the UK's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), and the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS). This multi-jurisdictional oversight means clients across different regions benefit from localised protections, segregated client funds, and consistent conduct standards regardless of where they trade.
Freetrade, founded in 2016, is regulated exclusively by the FCA. While FCA oversight is genuinely robust and means UK clients are protected under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) up to £85,000, the single-regulator structure does limit Freetrade's reach. Traders or investors based outside the UK have far fewer protections and fewer options when engaging with Freetrade compared to CMC Markets.
On the safety front, CMC Markets is the clear winner. Its longer operating history, broader regulatory footprint, and established compliance infrastructure provide a meaningfully higher degree of institutional confidence. For any trader who prioritises the security of their capital above all else, CMC Markets is the more trustworthy choice.
Fees, Spreads & Commissions
Freetrade's headline advantage is its pricing model: spreads start from 0 pips and there are zero commissions on trades. For a long-term investor buying and holding UK or US stocks and ETFs, this is genuinely compelling. There are no deposit fees and no withdrawal fees, making the total cost of ownership exceptionally low for straightforward buy-and-hold strategies. Freetrade does offer premium subscription tiers that unlock additional features, so it is worth reading the fine print before assuming everything is entirely free.
CMC Markets charges no commissions on CFD trades and imposes no deposit or withdrawal fees. However, spreads start from 0.7 pips on forex pairs, which is a more traditional pricing model for an active trading broker. For short-term traders executing high volumes of trades, even small spreads accumulate over time, so this is an important consideration. That said, 0.7 pips on major forex pairs is competitive within the CFD broker space and reflects CMC's institutional-grade liquidity access.
When comparing fees in isolation, Freetrade technically wins for stock investors due to its 0-pip spread starting point and commission-free structure. However, this comparison is somewhat misleading because Freetrade only covers stocks and ETFs, while CMC Markets spans six full market categories including forex, indices, commodities, and crypto. The two platforms are pricing models for fundamentally different use cases, and CMC Markets offers far greater value for active, diversified traders.
Trading Platforms & Technology
CMC Markets operates a proprietary web-based platform, a proprietary mobile application, and also supports MetaTrader 4 (MT4) — one of the most widely used and respected trading terminals in the world. The proprietary Next Generation platform is particularly well-regarded, offering advanced charting with over 115 technical indicators, pattern recognition tools, and a customisable interface that suits both intermediate and professional traders. The availability of MT4 is a significant bonus, allowing traders to run automated expert advisors (EAs) and access a global ecosystem of third-party tools.
Freetrade's technology offering is intentionally minimal by design. It operates a single proprietary mobile application, available on iOS and Android, which prioritises simplicity and ease of use over analytical depth. The app is clean, intuitive, and well-reviewed on app stores — but it offers no web platform, no desktop client, and no charting tools beyond basic price history. For a beginner making their first stock purchase, this is perfectly adequate. For anyone wanting to perform technical analysis or manage complex positions, it falls significantly short.
CMC Markets wins this category convincingly. The combination of its proprietary Next Generation platform, MT4 compatibility, and robust mobile application gives traders genuine flexibility across devices and strategies. Freetrade's mobile-only approach is a deliberate product decision aimed at simplicity, but it creates real limitations for traders who evolve beyond the basics.
Markets & Instruments
CMC Markets provides access to over 10,000 instruments spanning CFDs, forex, stocks, indices, commodities, and cryptocurrencies. This breadth is exceptional and positions CMC as one of the most comprehensive retail brokers available to UK and international traders. Whether you want to trade EUR/USD on forex, take a position on gold, speculate on a tech index, or access individual equities from global exchanges, CMC Markets has you covered under one roof.
Freetrade, by contrast, focuses exclusively on stocks and ETFs. While its library of available securities has grown since its 2016 launch and includes US and UK equities as well as a solid range of ETFs, it cannot be compared to CMC in terms of market diversity. There is no forex trading, no commodities exposure, no index CFDs, and no cryptocurrency trading available through Freetrade. This is a fundamental structural limitation for any trader looking to diversify beyond equity markets.
For investors whose entire strategy revolves around long-term stock and ETF accumulation, Freetrade's focused offering is not necessarily a weakness — it is a feature. Keeping things simple reduces the temptation to over-trade and helps beginners stay disciplined. But for anyone with a broader investment mandate, CMC Markets is the only viable choice between these two platforms.
Leverage & Trading Conditions
CMC Markets offers leverage of up to 1:500, which is among the highest available in the retail broker space. It is important to note that leverage limits vary by regulation — UK retail clients under FCA rules are capped at 1:30 for major forex pairs under ESMA guidelines, while professional clients and those trading through non-EU/UK entities may access higher leverage tiers. Regardless, the availability of meaningful leverage makes CMC Markets genuinely useful for active traders who want to amplify their market exposure with disciplined risk management.
Freetrade operates at a maximum leverage of 1:1, meaning there is no leverage whatsoever. This is entirely consistent with its product philosophy: Freetrade is built for investment, not speculation. Clients buy shares outright and own them directly, which is appropriate for a long-term, ISA-style investment approach. There is no margin trading, no short-selling, and no derivatives — which dramatically reduces risk but also eliminates entire categories of trading strategy.
The leverage disparity between these two brokers reflects a fundamental difference in purpose. CMC Markets is a trading platform; Freetrade is an investment platform. Neither is wrong, but they serve completely different financial goals. Traders seeking leverage, short positions, or derivative exposure have only one option here: CMC Markets.
Who Should Choose Which Broker?
CMC Markets is the right choice for experienced traders, those transitioning from beginner to intermediate level, forex traders, CFD traders, and anyone who wants access to a genuinely broad range of global markets through a professional-grade platform. Its three-decade track record, multi-regulator oversight, MT4 support, and 10,000+ instrument library make it one of the most well-rounded retail brokers available. The $0 minimum deposit removes the barrier to entry, making it accessible even for newer traders who are serious about developing their skills.
Freetrade is ideally suited to UK-based beginners who want to start investing in stocks and ETFs without paying commissions. Its Stocks and Shares ISA wrapper is a particularly attractive feature for UK investors seeking tax-efficient long-term growth. The mobile-first approach is perfectly matched to a generation of investors who prefer to manage their finances from a smartphone rather than a desktop terminal. If your goal is simple, disciplined, long-term equity investing, Freetrade delivers that experience cleanly and cheaply.
Our overall rating places CMC Markets at 4.0/5 and Freetrade at 3.0/5. CMC Markets wins on regulation, platform depth, market variety, and trading conditions. Freetrade wins on simplicity and raw cost efficiency for stock investors. Choose based on your strategy, not just the headline numbers.